Criminal Justice Developments This Week

Magistrates Court Sentencing Powers

The government is considering a significant change that could allow magistrates in England and Wales to hand down longer custodial sentences, potentially doubling the current maximum from six to twelve months. This proposal is part of broader efforts to alleviate pressure on both crown courts and the prison system.

The aim is to empower magistrates to deal with more serious cases, thereby reducing the number of cases referred to crown courts, which are already overwhelmed. This change could help address the backlog in crown courts, where long delays are affecting the administration of justice.

The Magistrates' Association has expressed support for the proposal. Chief Executive Tom Franklin described it as a "sensible move" that could speed up the justice process and ease the burden on prisons. In June, the remand population hit a record high of 17,000 people—comprising a fifth of the total prison population. Franklin emphasised that magistrates are already being trained to manage more complex cases, and this shift could help resolve delays that negatively impact victims, witnesses, and defendants alike.

However, critics, including Mary Prior KC, Chairwoman of the Criminal Bar Association, have raised concerns about the impact on prison overcrowding. She argued that increasing magistrates' sentencing powers could worsen the already critical situation in prisons. Prior pointed out that a similar initiative, introduced by former Justice Secretary Dominic Raab in 2022, was quickly abandoned due to its ineffectiveness.

This proposal comes on the heels of recent emergency measures to tackle prison overcrowding, including the early release of over 2,000 prisoners who had served just 40% of their sentences. Although this measure provided some relief to the prison system, it faced criticism after one individual reoffended immediately upon release.

While the government maintains that these steps are necessary to manage a system "on the brink of collapse," many stakeholders are calling for a broader approach. They emphasise the need for comprehensive reforms, including increased resources for courts and prisons, to address the underlying issues.

Cross-Border Security

In a significant move to tighten border security, the UK government has announced a £75 million investment through the creation of the new Border Security Command. This funding will bolster the National Crime Agency (NCA), police, and other law enforcement bodies in their efforts to combat criminal gangs involved in people smuggling, particularly those operating dangerous small boat crossings from the French coast.

The package includes advanced technology such as covert surveillance tools and enhanced intelligence gathering, as well as a substantial increase in personnel. The NCA will gain 100 additional investigators, and the number of British officers stationed at Europol will increase by 50%, focusing on dismantling organised crime networks responsible for human trafficking.

Home Secretary Yvette Cooper stressed the importance of this initiative in protecting lives and securing the UK's borders. NCA officials reiterated their commitment to targeting and disrupting human trafficking rings. The funding comes as part of wider efforts, including strengthened partnerships with European nations like Italy, to address shared migration challenges.

Martin Hewitt, the newly appointed Border Security Commander, will lead these efforts, ensuring that UK law enforcement and intelligence agencies work in a coordinated manner to combat the growing threat posed by people smuggling gangs.

How Can We Help?

We stay on top of all legislative changes and court developments to ensure we provide the most accurate and up-to-date legal advice. If you would like to discuss any aspect of your case, please contact our award-winning Crime Team.